star-art
Full Access Members
Having just spent literally months going through this (and having a brother who buys cars like he's a car dealer) I can say even though they are "no dicker" CarMax prices are inflated so don't use those to gauge true market value. The different "book" sources like NADA and Kelly Blue Book (KBB) are also biased towards dealers in their numbers.
What we found to be good practice is to look up your year, make, and model on KBB.com and then select "private party value." This is considerably lower than what dealers want to charge. You might have to fight like hell to get a truck from a dealer at a private party price. But, if you can at least get close, you will *know* you got the best deal possible.
For example, at the time I'm posting this, in my area a loaded 2017 XLT with really low miles (under 20K) prices anywhere from $39K - $44K. Several dealers have tried to sell them for $42K but they're not having much luck. When they lower the price below $40K they start to move. But, KBB "private party" for a truck like this in my area is as low as $35K. CarMax would probably ask at least $40K for the same truck.
Try to negotiate the price of your trade separately from the purchase price of the truck. Dealers try to roll it all in together which can be confusing (to their benefit). Know the "real" value of your trade. Don't be "fooled" if they offer more as it's just a game with the numbers. If they offer more for your trade, they are really taking less for their truck. To know if you got a good deal, use what you know is a realistic value for your trade and calculate from there. You can then see what they are really selling their truck for.
Hope that helps!
What we found to be good practice is to look up your year, make, and model on KBB.com and then select "private party value." This is considerably lower than what dealers want to charge. You might have to fight like hell to get a truck from a dealer at a private party price. But, if you can at least get close, you will *know* you got the best deal possible.
For example, at the time I'm posting this, in my area a loaded 2017 XLT with really low miles (under 20K) prices anywhere from $39K - $44K. Several dealers have tried to sell them for $42K but they're not having much luck. When they lower the price below $40K they start to move. But, KBB "private party" for a truck like this in my area is as low as $35K. CarMax would probably ask at least $40K for the same truck.
Try to negotiate the price of your trade separately from the purchase price of the truck. Dealers try to roll it all in together which can be confusing (to their benefit). Know the "real" value of your trade. Don't be "fooled" if they offer more as it's just a game with the numbers. If they offer more for your trade, they are really taking less for their truck. To know if you got a good deal, use what you know is a realistic value for your trade and calculate from there. You can then see what they are really selling their truck for.
Hope that helps!