I really miss the Gear Shift Lever

Disclaimer: Links on this page pointing to Amazon, eBay and other sites may include affiliate code. If you click them and make a purchase, we may earn a small commission.

TobyU

Full Access Members
Joined
Apr 5, 2013
Posts
2,479
Reaction score
869
Location
Ohio
This is essentially how our 2008 6 speed auto stick shift works. Put it in drive and the computer/transmission decides what gear you should be in. It has PRD21. If you place it in 2 or 1, the transmission down shifts until it gets to your selected gear. Use 2 to start on slippery or snowy roads and you have better traction because the transmission starts in 2nd. The "stick" is mechanically connected to the transmission, but the actual gear changes are made by solenoids in the valve body which are controlled by computer.
Quite a few cars have had the autostick for many years but I think what he's talking about is more like a traditional manual shifter. It's really not nearly as much fun just to bump it to the right each time you up shift or bump it down to downshift. I think the paddle shifters were a little bit more fun than that but what he really wants is a shifter that actually moves in an H pattern so you start in low and then you actually move the shifter 3 or 4 inches down to Second and then up and over to Third and back down to Fourth up and over the fifth etc.
Of course then you would really need a fake clutch pedal because your left foot would be pushing on the floorboard or feel very left out.
Maybe at the manufacturers would just give us the shifter then aftermarket could make a fake spring-loaded pedal 2 bolt to the floor over there.
If they really wanted to do it right and cover all bases they can put an electronic clutch pedal that literally disengaged the transmission or torque converter when you pushed it and where you had to push it to change gears with the shifter. So it would be the same activity as a manual transmission but it would be performed inside the transmission electronically.
A lot of people would absolutely love this but the problem is the added expense makes it where they're just not going to do it or even try.
You could literally have the best of all worlds though.
You could flip a switch and have to drive it like a mangle or put it in auto and just use the gas pedal.
 

larryjb

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jul 3, 2016
Posts
48
Reaction score
18
Location
Canada
I see now. When Maverick said "leave it in high gear and let the transmission decide", I thought he meant something else.

Yeah, I don't see enough customers wanting such a system in an Expedition.
 

Deadman

Full Access Members
Joined
Mar 17, 2019
Posts
2,458
Reaction score
1,572
Location
Wisconsin
I love a manual gearbox, but NOT in this big suv. I'd put it in every sports car, etc but not this gigantic SUV.
 

Bill Schell

Full Access Members
Joined
Aug 3, 2019
Posts
179
Reaction score
57
Location
Montana
I thought the rotary dial was weird and I didn't really like it. But now I'm use to it and after have a column shift or center console lever, actually finding the change OK.
 

Deadman

Full Access Members
Joined
Mar 17, 2019
Posts
2,458
Reaction score
1,572
Location
Wisconsin
Every time I get back in my wife vehicles with a mechanical console floor style gear shifter, I remember how much I miss that gear selector!
 

1970Maverick

Full Access Members
Joined
Aug 11, 2019
Posts
253
Reaction score
113
Location
orlando, fl
I see now. When Maverick said "leave it in high gear and let the transmission decide", I thought he meant something else.

Yeah, I don't see enough customers wanting such a system in an Expedition.

Tobyu understood what I was trying to express. I do like his idea for the spring loaded 3rd pedal to keep the left foot involved and also disengage the transmission or torque converter when you pushed it. My comment about leaving it in 6th would be the equivalent of "D" and the computer know that it has control. Doesn't seem too far out since the trans is already electro/mechanical in by design.
 
Top