In the mid 90's, Honda sold one for my 1992 Civic at the time. Once I sewed it on, it looked like it came with the car from the factory! It's all in how you sew it on. The one the OP used looks good, but could look OEM with a different and tightly pulled stitch pattern.
On my 1999 EB I received in October, the top of the steering wheel is almost worn away and everything I've seen online just doesn't look great. You really want a folded over seam where the two ends meet at the stitching. The ones which are simply a strip of leather will never look factory unfortunately.
Anyway, last month for only $6.99 new, I found a decent pleather slip-on cover which actually looks good for what it is, until I find the right sewn-on cover. You never know what you'll find at Goodwill....