OK, I swapped out the T-Stat and it wasn't that bad. When I took the hose off it appeared to be closed because when I popped out the O-ring it started to come up from the block. Upper hose appeared to be full as almost half or a full gallon spilled out from it. No debris or sludge or any particles did I see. Pressing on it it feels fine almost like the new one that went in.
Here is the old one I took out
Fluid that spilled out was a slightly darker orange than the orange stuff I had, it had a little brown tint to it but was definitely orange and could tell not so brown as I thought. Guess looking into the degas tank made it appear darker than it really was.
Didn't do the flush, can't find my piping and stuff to do it like the video, and have it all buttoned up now. Got the car running for almost an hour again and it seems a little warmer now out of the vents but it also went up to 33 degrees here (from 26 this morning when I tested last). A good quality temp gauge says its 84 degrees in the car with the heat blasting for over an hour and the doors and windows closed up. That is better than 60 or so which was about the best I could get it before, but that was on a day it was only 10 degrees outside when I tested that. Heater was barely defrosting the window, had to drive with windows open.
OBD said that BEFORE the T-Stat was changed coolant was 185 and stayed there for an hour and only went up or down a degree or two 184-187
After the T-Stat went in, it only went up a few degrees. I got it up to 199 for a second or two revving and holding it at 2500 or so. But now it stays at 192-194 or so (more so rock steady at 192) for past hour. Not a huge difference really I think but it did rise up a few degrees from 185 and stays at 192 for the past hour rock steady.
But it does seem a bit warmer now... (but it isn't 10 degrees outside yet) have to see what it does when its zero or -10 again. Maybe the lines need to be flushed, but why a water pump? How do metal propellers go bad?
FYI - factory temp gauge is right at where it was before, almost dead center in the middle from slightly above center (but again it is a factory idiot gauge). I can hold the heater hose for almost a half min, its not hot hot hot but I can almost take it for a half min or so. No pressure in the lines at all, I can squeeze them just fine including the upper main radiator hose. Main hose I can hold all day long, just warm... Heater hose gets a little uncomfortable but not like I'm touching something almost 200 degrees. Maybe the thick heater hose and ambient air is providing a sort of cooling effect insulated it from what it really is. Don't have an IR temp gun.... maybe the next toy I buy.
Does any of this help at all?
I'm gunna have to fill up again, gas station is going to love me!