Who will primarily be sitting in the 2nd row? If you have kids, the bench usually makes more sense even if you plan to remove the center seat.
If you don’t have kids and will primarily have adults in the 2nd and 3rd row, the captain’s chairs are a nice option but I wouldn’t say necessary.
I’ve done a 5 hour road trip in the 2nd row bench seat and didn’t find it uncomfortable.
This is exactly why you should have the option or both when you buy it.
I have heard people with kids that want the console but remove it so the kids can walk through to the 3rd row easier. Other people kneel in there to put younger ones in 3rd row boosters or car seats. One poster said his kids just hop over the top of the bench.
I don't car which one is more comfortable as I won't be sitting in either. In all the SUVs we've owned I might have been in one of the 2nd or 3rd row ones once or twice tying to lay down and sleep on a trip. I am either in driver or passenger seat.
The buckets are nice as the console acts as an armrest and without it they feel terrible without armrests like van captain chairs.
I wan't the extra person capacity BIG TIME! I am ok if the center seat back folds down to an armrest or writing table but I want 3 people in the 2nd row capacity.
The 2nd gen Navigators did it all wrogn and the new Explorers got it right ....IF you are only going to seat 7, then the 3 should be in 2nd then the 2 in 3rd IF YOU can't make the 3rd big enough for 3 like the Explorer.
If you are picking up kids etc as most people who move people around are moving their kids and their friends...When you roll up to pick them up and there is 3, they have to flip a seat to get to back row. If the 2nd row is 3, they don't. So all SUVS should have 3 person 2nd rows regardless of 3rd row design.
Seating 1 additional person is a big win and a Navigator with console loses. The extra elegance doesn't make p for the one extra person. An Expediton with leather and 8 pass beats a Navi with 7 every time. Unless you don't move people..Then I see no big need for SUV!
I have owned a lot...wait I should type that A LOT!!!! of vehicles I did not need. Hovercraft, limos, firetruck, monster trucks, drag bikes, baja beetle bug, sandrail, conversion vans, etc so I fully understand just wanting an SUV because you like the look and never having over 1-2 passengers with you the whole time you have it.
But if you don;t haul people around there are trucks and 4 door trucks that give you more functionality than an SUV.
They tried to combine the two but never worked for me.
Until they make a 3 row SUV and add a bed to it, it won't work for me.