6 month review, 18 Navigator VS 18 Expedition.

Disclaimer: Links on this page pointing to Amazon, eBay and other sites may include affiliate code. If you click them and make a purchase, we may earn a small commission.

Deadman

Full Access Members
Joined
Mar 17, 2019
Posts
2,561
Reaction score
1,684
Location
Wisconsin
I just wanted to throw out a little review/comparison since I have both of these vehicles. I've now owned the Navigator about 6 months and my Expedition like 2 years.

The vehicles. 2018 Ford Expedition Limited 302A 4x4 Max tow package white. 20,000 miles now.
2018 Lincoln Navigator L Black Label 4x4 white. 18,000 miles now


I just recently took both of these vehicles on a fairly long road trip on the same road, so it was a very good comparison in my opinion. Both vehicles have the same 3.73 gears, both have 22's on identical tires, both are the Max version, both are 4x4, so they are set up VERY similiarly. The ONLY mods to either vehicle are front and rear Hellwig sway bars on my Expedition. Otherwise its just simple stuff like floor mats and such.....

First off I know my Expedition has the sway bars updated, but I will say the Expedition drives, handles, rides 3X better than the Navigator does. The Navigators stock suspension settings (in normal mode) are extremely stiff and it actually wheel hops on cracks in the road because the suspension is so damn stiff. I've deathly afraid to add sway bars to it as it will get stiffer yet and be miserable to ride in.

Ride quality (both in normal modes), the Expedition rides tons better. You don't feel the seams, cracks, etc in the roads whereas the Navigator transfers EVERY one of those cracks thru the car and shakes and bounces etc. The Navigator with its factory sway bars sways all over the highway at higher speeds (just like my Expedition did before swapping the sway bars). I mean it just dances in the wind, you constantly have to play with the steering in the wind to keep it on your lane. My expedition lays on the road 3X as flat and doesn't dance around like the Lincoln does. The Expedition will take the same corner at 80 mph and feel better than the Navigator can at 60 mph. The Lincoln leans in the corners and makes you think you are going too fast where the Expedition lays flat in the corners and "hugs" the road. If there's a bump in a high speed corner, you need to hold onto the Lincoln whereas the Expedition just stays right on track and eats the bump. So honestly they aren't even in the same league in my opinion.... (yes my sway bars the answer, I know).

Power, real simple, the Lincoln SMOKES the expedition. The trans in the Lincoln wants to downshift ALL the time and its annoying. On some hills the Lincoln was down in 8th gear and my Expedition NEVER left 10th gear on these same hills, roads. MPG I'm not even getting into because the Expedition fought 35Mph head winds the entire trip and the Navigator didn't and I honestly couldn't tell you how to reset all the electronic BS on that complicated Lincoln. lol.

Interior wise, the Lincoln is hands down nicer, but everything is delicate and wants to scratch whereas my Expedition has padded arm rests and stuff that is less prone to all the scratching of daily use. The Lincoln has this HUGE center console thing that makes me feel very claustrophobic because it hugs you and is much taller than the Ford. The push buttons on the Lincoln work fine, but I'm not familiar with them so EVERY time I wanted to shift gears I had to stop and look where to push. In my Expedition I keep my hand on the knob and just turn it a click or 2 and I know what gear its in without taking my eyes off of the mirrors and such. The electronic BS on the Lincoln is annoying to say the least. I HATE the gross touch screen thrown on the dash, but luckily I can control most things with buttons yet.

End result, they are both great but the Expedition is just a better performer on the road right now. The seats are so huge in the Navigator that they waste a lot of space in the 2nd row. I'm not kidding you, these seats are HUGE and THICK. They make a huge blindspot when looking for traffic coming from your right side. The seats are so big that it makes it hard getting the kids into their car seats in the 2nd row as theres just no room left and the stupid TV's stick out another 3-5 inches beyond that.

Needless to say the Expedition is our road trip car, the Lincoln can stay as my wifes daily driver.

Hope this helps any of you wondering about the 2 and their differences.
 

byathread

Full Access Members
Joined
May 8, 2019
Posts
267
Reaction score
159
Location
Pennsylvania
I'd love to drive an expedition max with the helwigs to feel the difference/gauge if the upgrade is worth it. Would you still do both or just the rear of you had to do it again?
I don't think I drive that hard, but have noticed "motion" in this beast. [emoji23]

Nice write up, @Deadman, thank you...
 
OP
OP
D

Deadman

Full Access Members
Joined
Mar 17, 2019
Posts
2,561
Reaction score
1,684
Location
Wisconsin
I'd love to drive an expedition max with the helwigs to feel the difference/gauge if the upgrade is worth it. Would you still do both or just the rear of you had to do it again?
I don't think I drive that hard, but have noticed "motion" in this beast. [emoji23]

Nice write up, @Deadman, thank you...

Honestly, the rear bar mainly helped the sway and bobblehead movement it gave all the passengers. The front bar "glued" this thing to the road and made it handle flat like a performance sedan does. The front bar took the last of the bobblehead motion out as well. If you ONLY did one bar, for sure the rear is the one.

I didn't drive mine hard BEFORE the sway bars because it was so clumsy and tippy/leaning. Now its so sure-footed that it feels so much better doing anything at speed. I've noticed right after th sway bars that the brakes are NOW weak! lol. I never pushed it before because it handled soo horribly that I couldn't notice the brakes. Either way, its just soooo much more confident on the road now.
 

carymccarr

Full Access Members
Joined
Aug 11, 2019
Posts
1,749
Reaction score
390
Location
Earth
Wow, I’ve never experienced the highway play that you’re describing nor the transmission/shudder of road “noise” transmitted to the cabin or wheel. I tend to keep mine in conserve mode on the highway and that could be it.

I have a 2020 though...wonder if they made some small tweaks/changes from 18-20.

Glad you like your expy, I just can’t get past the interior but recognize that’s all aesthetic opinion.

Good write up!
 
OP
OP
D

Deadman

Full Access Members
Joined
Mar 17, 2019
Posts
2,561
Reaction score
1,684
Location
Wisconsin
Wow, I’ve never experienced the highway play that you’re describing nor the transmission/shudder of road “noise” transmitted to the cabin or wheel. I tend to keep mine in conserve mode on the highway and that could be it.

I have a 2020 though...wonder if they made some small tweaks/changes from 18-20.

Glad you like your expy, I just can’t get past the interior but recognize that’s all aesthetic opinion.

Good write up!

It rides better in Conserve, for sure. I did try that, but then the trans gets extremely sluggish and its very lazy feeling. But it does ride better, but still not as smooth as my Expedition in normal.
 
OP
OP
D

Deadman

Full Access Members
Joined
Mar 17, 2019
Posts
2,561
Reaction score
1,684
Location
Wisconsin
To touch more on the power differences. The expedition feels similar in power until you reach like 45, then the expedition kinda lays down and that HO just rips thru the gears. Passing in the HO can literally get me in trouble. I've passed cars on small rural highways with 55mph speed limits and I've seen it over 90 mph if I really get after it just passing a single car, it really moves.....
 

TheDoug

Full Access Members
Joined
Apr 20, 2019
Posts
607
Reaction score
345
Location
Mansfield, TX
Thanks for posting this, I was torn between the 2. I ultimately decided on expy platinum because I got a great deal. I love the looks of the navi from front but I could not make myself like what they did at the rear.
 

mcb345

Full Access Members
Joined
Oct 11, 2020
Posts
210
Reaction score
81
Location
Nashville, TN
First off I know my Expedition has the sway bars updated, but I will say the Expedition drives, handles, rides 3X better than the Navigator does. The Navigators stock suspension settings (in normal mode) are extremely stiff and it actually wheel hops on cracks in the road because the suspension is so damn stiff. I've deathly afraid to add sway bars to it as it will get stiffer yet and be miserable to ride in.

Ride quality (both in normal modes), the Expedition rides tons better. You don't feel the seams, cracks, etc in the roads whereas the Navigator transfers EVERY one of those cracks thru the car and shakes and bounces etc. The Navigator with its factory sway bars sways all over the highway at higher speeds (just like my Expedition did before swapping the sway bars). I mean it just dances in the wind, you constantly have to play with the steering in the wind to keep it on your lane. My expedition lays on the road 3X as flat and doesn't dance around like the Lincoln does. The Expedition will take the same corner at 80 mph and feel better than the Navigator can at 60 mph. The Lincoln leans in the corners and makes you think you are going too fast where the Expedition lays flat in the corners and "hugs" the road. If there's a bump in a high speed corner, you need to hold onto the Lincoln whereas the Expedition just stays right on track and eats the bump. So honestly they aren't even in the same league in my opinion.... (yes my sway bars the answer, I know).

I’d say the ride quality in my expedition with CCD is pretty disappointing. I’m running stock 22’s with stock tires inflated to recommended 39 psi and I feel everything, little road imperfections, bumps, rough asphalt, etc. But, I’m coming from smaller luxury crossover and sedans so maybe I’m not used to the body on farm ride?

Its a used CPO 2019 with 27k miles so I would think it’s not busted in any way shape or form but who knows!
 

grumpyoleman

Full Access Members
Joined
Apr 17, 2019
Posts
140
Reaction score
146
Location
flyover country
I’d say the ride quality in my expedition with CCD is pretty disappointing. I’m running stock 22’s with stock tires inflated to recommended 39 psi and I feel everything, little road imperfections, bumps, rough asphalt, etc. But, I’m coming from smaller luxury crossover and sedans so maybe I’m not used to the body on farm ride?

Its a used CPO 2019 with 27k miles so I would think it’s not busted in any way shape or form but who knows!

I have the XLT with no CCD and 18" wheels. Smooth as silk. I have heard the larger wheels (less rubber/sidewall) make a huge difference. not so sure about CCD.
 
OP
OP
D

Deadman

Full Access Members
Joined
Mar 17, 2019
Posts
2,561
Reaction score
1,684
Location
Wisconsin
I’d say the ride quality in my expedition with CCD is pretty disappointing. I’m running stock 22’s with stock tires inflated to recommended 39 psi and I feel everything, little road imperfections, bumps, rough asphalt, etc. But, I’m coming from smaller luxury crossover and sedans so maybe I’m not used to the body on farm ride?

Its a used CPO 2019 with 27k miles so I would think it’s not busted in any way shape or form but who knows!

Not sure, but mine rides amazing. I just put 2,000 miles on it and theres absolutely no way we felt the road seams or anything like that in mine. The sway bars stiffened my suspension up a little, so it should ride stiffer than yours if anything. I'm running the factory tires simply because they are soooo quiet. They are useless in snow, but I've got better snow vehicles for snow days. Is yours a MAX? If not, it's possibly the shorter wheelbase and lighter weight not flexing the spring rates as well as the heavier max does...
 
OP
OP
D

Deadman

Full Access Members
Joined
Mar 17, 2019
Posts
2,561
Reaction score
1,684
Location
Wisconsin
I have the XLT with no CCD and 18" wheels. Smooth as silk. I have heard the larger wheels (less rubber/sidewall) make a huge difference. not so sure about CCD.


Less sidewall definately hurts ride quality, but it helps stability. I like the stable feeling vs the sloppy sidewall of a smaller diameter wheel. My pickup slops around on its rubber because its on old 16" wheels and its very noticeable even tho they are Load Range E 10 ply tires. Just more rubber to move around.....
 

grumpyoleman

Full Access Members
Joined
Apr 17, 2019
Posts
140
Reaction score
146
Location
flyover country
Less sidewall definately hurts ride quality, but it helps stability. I like the stable feeling vs the sloppy sidewall of a smaller diameter wheel. .

Touche' there is definitely a trade off for most everything. I prefer the smooth ride and have not noticed any issues whatsoever with stability, but then again - I drive like an old man.....
Guess that is why we have so many options :)
 

Anerbe

Full Access Members
Joined
Oct 16, 2020
Posts
122
Reaction score
76
Location
Mi
Perhaps it's perspective. The 22"/CCD Platinum is worlds smoother than both our old '16 explorer limited in terms of expansion joint absorption (less impact feel), while the long rental 2020 F150 sport seemed oversprung with offset of tall sidewall (felt the impacts, but much softer). I expect the expedition to still have more impact than a luxury CUV/passcar, as it needs to be able to handle higher loads, requiring higher spring rates.
 

mcb345

Full Access Members
Joined
Oct 11, 2020
Posts
210
Reaction score
81
Location
Nashville, TN
Not sure, but mine rides amazing. I just put 2,000 miles on it and theres absolutely no way we felt the road seams or anything like that in mine. The sway bars stiffened my suspension up a little, so it should ride stiffer than yours if anything. I'm running the factory tires simply because they are soooo quiet. They are useless in snow, but I've got better snow vehicles for snow days. Is yours a MAX? If not, it's possibly the shorter wheelbase and lighter weight not flexing the spring rates as well as the heavier max does...

mine is not a Max so yes, perhaps shorter wheelbase or whatnot is detrimental. It doesn’t seem like the bumps feel any different from Fromt to back so probably just me not being too familiar with body on frame ride quality?

I did notice my tires have a little more wear in the middle of the tread so I may run them a few PSI lower for 5-10k miles to even it out. Should help with ride quality a bit!
 

vincentrose

Well-Known Member
Joined
Nov 1, 2020
Posts
93
Reaction score
46
Location
Kershaw, SC
The Lincoln is just a little bit too classy for me, so for me the easy choice was the Ford, also on the 4WD version, on the Lincoln Navigator, you only get a 1 Speed Transfer Case, but on the Ford Expedition, you get a 2 Speed Transfer Case, so no 4X4 Low Option on the Lincoln. Glad I picked the Ford
 
OP
OP
D

Deadman

Full Access Members
Joined
Mar 17, 2019
Posts
2,561
Reaction score
1,684
Location
Wisconsin
The Lincoln is just a little bit too classy for me, so for me the easy choice was the Ford, also on the 4WD version, on the Lincoln Navigator, you only get a 1 Speed Transfer Case, but on the Ford Expedition, you get a 2 Speed Transfer Case, so no 4X4 Low Option on the Lincoln. Glad I picked the Ford


Thats another annoyance with the Lincoln. To put the Lincoln in 4x4, you need to spin that damn knob and watch the dash to see what mode you are going into without crashing. On my Ford I can just simply press the 4A button and put my eyes back on the road. I hate that stupid drive mode contraption on both vehicles... I never use it.
 
Top