This morning I was getting an oil change and I spent some time with an '18 Navigator Black Label with the Destination theme. There are three themes you can choose from with a new Navigator which dictate the primary colors of the interior: Yacht Club (Blue), Destination (Burgundy) and Chalet (Cream).
Comparing to my '16 Expy Platinum (which I love dearly), the interior of the Navigator is on a completely different level. Lincoln definitely went for the modern ultra-luxury feel, much like GM did with the Escalade.
Frankly, I didn't like the rim design, but they fit the overall theme well. I grabbed the front grille expecting it to be made of plastic and have some minor play (much like plastic frome); however I was surprised that the grille is either made of metal or reinforced plastic, because it had no play and felt solid. As I continued to explore, I focused on finding minor details where "refined" is Lincoln's intended impression.
So while the trucks may be cut from the same cloth, it's the attitude between the two which are night and day different.
Starting with the names...
"Expedition" is an action word, a "do-it" word. Expedition says adventure, trail-blazing, pack leading, boldness, going somewhere excluded and difficult.
"Navigator" is a directing word, a planning word. Navigator makes the decision of we are going here. I will direct you where to go, but you do the heavy lifting. The Navigator says I'm the planner, the overseeer, the ultimately responsible, but I'm not the deck hand or the line man.
Honestly, this is why I chose my Expy and would choose the Expy Platinum over the Navigator, even today. Despite the refinements on a Platinum, it's still an Expedition. To me, this says capable, strong, tough, ballsy. The Expy still gives you a true 2 speed 4x4 transfer case, whereas the Navigator does not. Even with '20s, the Expedition tires still have a good amount of sidewall meat on them; pointing to the tough-duty roots of the Expedition. Even while I stop at a light sitting on cooled red-cherry leather shadowed by an open moon roof, illuminated by LEDs; I can still pull up next to an LEO Expedition Interceptor with a winch, steel rims, Kevlar tires and bull bar.
On the other hand, a Navigator is all about screaming luxury. No expense spared, the Navigator is the voice for demand of the most comfortable and fashionable. The Navigator says: I don't need a true 2 speed 4x4 transfer case, because I helicopter to destinations off the beaten path. I need 22's with low profile tires because that's what grabs the attention at the valet. The suspension should be about comfort, not capacity, because I don't use my truck for heavy duty tasks. But with those qualities, comes the sacrifice of the tough, off-roady, business feel of the Expedition.
I don't mean any of this in a sarcastic way and I'm not shunning the Navigator at all; it's just built for a different purpose.
They have certainly done wonders to differentiate the Navigator from the Expy since the very first model; a re-badging exercise with cooled seats and an Alpine. On that front, I was incredibly impressed.