Won’t start after releasing shifter out of park

Disclaimer: Links on this page pointing to Amazon, eBay and other sites may include affiliate code. If you click them and make a purchase, we may earn a small commission.

StillTrying

New Member
Joined
Jul 4, 2025
Posts
4
Reaction score
3
Location
NC
2016 Expy
Found shifter release, got in neutral, will not crank, and brake pedal is now very stiff, brake lights work, new battery, new alternator, and we just got the car a couple weeks ago.

Expy now at stealership on a holiday weekend.

Any suggestions much appreciated. Don’t want dealer just throwing parts in hoping for a fix
 

99WhiteC5Coupe

Full Access Members
Joined
Jun 3, 2015
Posts
3,445
Reaction score
2,026
Location
USA
2016 Expy
Found shifter release, got in neutral, will not crank, and brake pedal is now very stiff, brake lights work, new battery, new alternator, and we just got the car a couple weeks ago.

Expy now at stealership on a holiday weekend.

Any suggestions much appreciated. Don’t want dealer just throwing parts in hoping for a fix


Your post is a little confusing.

Would the vehicle not crank or start while the transmission selector was in the park-position?

Why was a new battery and alternator installed?

Does the chime sound when the LF door is opened, and the key (or fob) is not in the start or accessory position?

If so, there may be an issue with the transmission shifter assembly. It is a known problem on the 2015 - 2017 models. A part breaks inside the shifter assembly, causing the computer to think the car is not in neutral or park, which prevents the vehicle from cranking.

There are several posts on this forum about the problem.
 
OP
OP
S

StillTrying

New Member
Joined
Jul 4, 2025
Posts
4
Reaction score
3
Location
NC
Hey 99WhiteC5Coupe, I bought new a white 1970 Corvette, 350hp 350 torque. Drove hard for 120k miles (++ tickets) Prob my favorite car during my 55 years of driving!

Many thanks for your time !

The Expy is my daughter / son in law’s vehicle. He told me, but I can’t remember all the details re the new battery & alternator = two different repair shops. Something about the battery guy not tightening the ? On the battery. 3rd shop = at their trusted home town mechanic = all seemed Ok… The car was inspected, engine ?flushed due to very dirty spark plugs (replaced) - Then they drove it 120 miles to our home + 2-3 more trips locally before the stoppage.

The car would not start while in park or after: Jiggled the steering wheel, brake lights worked, tricked it into neutral, removed the very small panel on the console pushed on the surface inside … none of these enabled starting the vehicle.

Not sure re your other Q’s. We tried several fixes but it was hot + small child + lots of groceries so he just had it towed to the dealer.

The goal of our research is to best understand the possible solutions so when the dealer presents their suggested fix we know whether to get a second opinion.

We read lots of posts etc on the Web and this site but can’t try them since the car is at the dealer.

Several solutions include:
For starting(we were able to get the shifter in neutral):
** jiggle the key in ignition
** low or dead battery in fob
** stuck or broken button in shifter mechanism under the shifter console
** ? Pawl stuck in transmission
** close drivers door
** Parking brake on or stuck = find way to release or unstick
** Fuse related to car computer not recognizing car is in park or OK to start
** Ignition mechanism broken

Again many thanks for your time and other comments you may have.

Regards,
Tom
 

99WhiteC5Coupe

Full Access Members
Joined
Jun 3, 2015
Posts
3,445
Reaction score
2,026
Location
USA
Hey 99WhiteC5Coupe, I bought new a white 1970 Corvette, 350hp 350 torque. Drove hard for 120k miles (++ tickets) Prob my favorite car during my 55 years of driving!

Many thanks for your time !

The Expy is my daughter / son in law’s vehicle. He told me, but I can’t remember all the details re the new battery & alternator = two different repair shops. Something about the battery guy not tightening the ? On the battery. 3rd shop = at their trusted home town mechanic = all seemed Ok… The car was inspected, engine ?flushed due to very dirty spark plugs (replaced) - Then they drove it 120 miles to our home + 2-3 more trips locally before the stoppage.

The car would not start while in park or after: Jiggled the steering wheel, brake lights worked, tricked it into neutral, removed the very small panel on the console pushed on the surface inside … none of these enabled starting the vehicle.

Not sure re your other Q’s. We tried several fixes but it was hot + small child + lots of groceries so he just had it towed to the dealer.

The goal of our research is to best understand the possible solutions so when the dealer presents their suggested fix we know whether to get a second opinion.

We read lots of posts etc on the Web and this site but can’t try them since the car is at the dealer.

Several solutions include:
For starting(we were able to get the shifter in neutral):
** jiggle the key in ignition
** low or dead battery in fob
** stuck or broken button in shifter mechanism under the shifter console
** ? Pawl stuck in transmission
** close drivers door
** Parking brake on or stuck = find way to release or unstick
** Fuse related to car computer not recognizing car is in park or OK to start
** Ignition mechanism broken

Again many thanks for your time and other comments you may have.

Regards,
Tom


I don’t have any other suggestions but wish you luck with the repair. Please post the resolution at the dealer.

To give away my age - my first Corvette was a 1965 convertible: 327 / 325 hp + four speed and both tops.

My second Corvette was a 1973 coupe: L48 - automatic. I kept that one until I bought the 1999 Corvette coupe new.

Best wishes!
 
OP
OP
S

StillTrying

New Member
Joined
Jul 4, 2025
Posts
4
Reaction score
3
Location
NC
Hey 99, at 73 - any Corvette would be easy to fall into but hard to get out of. I bought a ‘24 Mazda CX30 with a Turbo. Very smooth acceleration and even after 8k I have not yet tested the real power. The power so far is “good and plenty” = quite zippy.

The dealer is replacing the starter, per their recommendation. This makes sense as it would not start when I was able to get the shifter into neutral. I’ll keep you posted re potential new surprises.

Regards,

Tom

P.S. S-I-L said the new battery was not properly connected hence making the alternator work harder trying to charge it. When checking the battery - one connection was very hot. All this caused the alternator to fail. Then new alternator installed and battery properly connected = good to go. I wonder if the above caused the starter to fail ????
 
Last edited:
Top