For all the OE marked tires: BMW Star, Mercedes MO, etc... which come on their vehicles, are you saying that none of those are available in the aftermarket? All of the star marked BMW runflats to buy from Tirerack are actually a completely separate developed runflat marked with BMW?
Simple way to verify is check the full DOT codes of the tires you receive as aftermarket and compare to the original tires on the vehicle (or the P/N). I'm sure you'll find most of the same size / product line specs have the same DOT code as what was found on the vehicle (except the date code obviously).
No, if you saw the previous posts, and the one I replied to, i was specifically talking about the tires that are created specifically for OEM use, that, and to you response, Hankook makes tires for Ford that actually use the exact same series and models, but are slightly different to decrease costs. As I said, having worked at one of the largest tire shops out there, we used to do that a lot. We would get someone in that had a road hazard issue on a set of stock tires, and even if we had the same tire in stock, it may have actually had different DOT certs. Sometimes it's things like trad depth may be a little less, composition might be slightly different, in fact, some brands are making tires different right now so that car manufacturers can pass EPA requirements a little easier. But the consumer version of that very same tire may be different.
All I was referring to is those "custom" versions for vehicle manufacturers aren't typically going to show up on aftermarket sites, as they aren't orderable by consumers. And just as a side note, I actually had this exact issue on my last vehicle. Destroyed a stock tire offroad, and the not only was the replacement slightly higher tread depth than the stock tires (and they only had about 2k miles on them), but they were stiffer. Which was noticeable in some conditions.