Power mirror mod: new OEM, used OEM, or LKQ/aftermarket?

[rwmorrisonjr]

As the title says, I'm weighing options for the power mirror upgrade on my 2012 EB XLT. I can go with new OEM, used OEM, or LKQ/aftermarket. It all comes down to price and quality. I'd like to keep the spotter glass, but that's a low priority for me. I've posted the links below, and a poll above, so please share your votes and thoughts!

New OEM:

LH: Brand New LH Exterior Rear Mirror Assembly 2012 2013 Navigator Expedition | eBay

RH: Brand New RH Exterior Rear Mirror Assembly 2012 2013 Navigator Expedition | eBay

Used OEM:

RH: 12 13 Ford Expedition Right Side View Mirror Power Folding Signal | eBay

*I'd buy the LH used OEM as it comes available

LKQ/AM:

LH: New Mirror Driver Left Side Heated Power Folding in Housing Turn Signal Light LH | eBay

RH: New Mirror Passenger Right Side Power Folding Heated with Memory RH Hand Ford | eBay

 

[k9education]

I'd be hesitant to go AM without being able to easily return it if the fit isn't right. However, the prices on the OEM pieces - even used - are ridiculous. I'd stick with the manual mirrors before I'd pay $800 for a pair.

 

[drokmofo]

I had to replace my passenger side power fold. Oem was around $500. I went to Amazon and found some from Kool Vue for $150. Done. Easy replacement.