Happened to me as well about 2 weeks ago. Brought it in yesterday. Tech didn't even try to disassemble the console or anything, just said "yeah it's broken - need to replace" and I now have a quote of $630 to fix (granted that's in Canadian Loonies, so a mere US$500). I haven't seen anyone answer 5280tunage when he asked how hard it is to fix... searching for videos I found exactly one that shows lifting the upper console piece off (but it's not the Expy console so hopefully it works on my 2018 XLT). I'd like to explore fixing it somehow before buying a new one that'll just do it again... anyone who has done this have any tips? Were these bottoms actually glued on originally, or were they clipped on somehow?
Oh, and yes, that is my last visit to that dealership for service. Long sad story about the rapid decline of a once-good company...
And I also agree with the statements about this being a very poor design.